Saturday, Feb 11, 2012
Login

Should I Look at the Scale?

Here’s a question that gets asked a lot:  “Should you look at the scale?”

I think absolutely you should* if fat loss is your goal. I know others will tell you to “ignore the scale,” but it is the most objective way to tell if you have your energy balance right for fat loss. When we add exercise to our regime, it is SO easy to overcompensate on the calories we think we are burning. We pour the cereal for a few seconds longer, we add just a little more peanut butter to our toast, we take just a few more noodles every time we have pasta– we don’t even notice it, but before we know it we’ve totally equalized or, worse, flipped the energy equation. Weighing and measuring food is one way to make sure this isn’t happening, weighing and measuring your body is the other.

It also bears mentioning that exercise has been proven to have more than just a physical effect, it also has a mental one. It improves mood, outlook and self esteem (all great things!) Unfortunately, what this can mean is that maybe we’re standing a little taller, looking at ourselves through different eyes, feeling great about ourselves and, thus, seeing some changes that might not really be there;  The scale and the tape measure are two totally objective tests that won’t lie to ya. Especially if we are getting fit for health vs vanity, we need to move beyond the mirror and put some numbers behind it.

*To preserve your sanity, I suggest weighing only once per week, at the same time of day, under the same conditions, otherwise the waterweight fluctuations will drive you batty.  If you insist on weighing yourself every day, use a tool like Google 15 to give yourself a running average and make adjustments to your program based on the average, not the day-to-day fluctuations.


1 Comment

  1. So after about 5 minutes of careful consideration about three weeks ago my girlfriend and I decided that we would need six packs. We’re only 23 but in God-awful shape. Wheezing up a flight of stairs kind of stuff.

    We’ll be making our first trip down to Bonnaroo (if you don’t know what that is, Google it and then make the trip down…we need a bigger caravan!) It’s imperative that we be able to take our shirts off and ‘wave them around our heads like helicopters’ without causing anyone to go blind or puke at the above mentioned hippy festival.

    We’re about 2 weeks into P90X and I think the most important lesson I’ve learned so far is the one you talk about above. I was driving myself nuts weighing myself within about 3 minutes of waking up every morning. Then sometimes at lunch. Then after dinner. After I got out of the shower. After I worked out. Before I went to bed. It just kept going from 140 to 138. Back and forth. I’d have dreams about it.

    So this week, we’re trying something new. Just like you suggested, I weighed myself on Monday morning. And I haven’t looked at the scale since. I can’t wait until I get to tomorrow morning…but even if I haven’t lost a pound…I feel better. More fit. Less flabby. I even sprouted two (TWO!!) semi-almost abs about two days ago. I’ve never had any stomach definition AT ALL. Imagine my shock and awe. All after a week and a half of diet and excercise. Who knew.

    This blog is amazing. You guys crack me up and I love how there’s info in here specifically for women…it’s answered a lot of questions I’ve had.
    Thanks for the information and the inspiration!

    (I’ll be sure to let you know when I find abs #3 and 4. They can’t be far behind!)

Leave a Reply